THE PERFORMER

Five and a half years after starting an independent adult-content career at 54, Elaina St. James, a Midwest mom with two books, a Business Insider feature she pitched herself and a son she raised on her own, talks about Dolly Parton, branding, the MILF niche, the studio performers she films with, AI chatbots, online scams and the family that stopped calling, and, for the record, downspouts.
Interview/Feature: Sherman Wayez
CHICAGO, ILL
THE BIG JOKE WAS ON EVERYONE ELSE
Elaina St. James came to talk about a career. She started with Dolly Parton. Parton had died the day before, and St. James, who has spent the last five and a half years as an independent creator, had already been talking with friends in the industry about how much the loss meant to them.
“There was something about a woman who was so strong and independent and so smart, but also very sexual,” she says. “She used it, and she acknowledged it, but she didn’t take herself too seriously. She leaned into the jokes, and the big joke was on everyone else who dismissed her as being dumb or just her boobs, when she was so much more. For anyone in an industry like ours that is focused on our looks, we feel that. We’re all business people. If we’re in this industry, especially if we’re independent creators, we are business people.”
St. James is 59 and remembers Parton from the 1970s.
“It really hit me. I’ve been a fan of her for as long as I can remember,” she says. “For people that create sexy content, spicy content, who are judged so much on their looks and not so much on the merits of being a business person, there’s a mix there. Me at 59, in this industry for five years, and the other women I’ve talked to, we are face first with our looks, and then the business is kind of secondary. I think that’s a lot of what Dolly dealt with as well, but she did it with such grace and humor and humility.”
Parton’s death sent her back to another one.
“I think everybody I’ve talked to, we really thought we had another 10 years with her. We thought she would live to a ripe old age,” she says. “I’m old enough to remember when Elvis died, and it was devastating. I was a huge fan of Elvis. He was very young, 42, she was 80, but still it just seems like too soon.”
Then there was the question of a proper memorial.
“I was talking to a friend of mine right before we got on here, and we were like, they better rename that Nashville airport to Dolly Parton International, because who else?” she says. “Who else are you ever gonna have that is so beloved by every facet? I’ve never heard anyone say a bad word about Dolly Parton. And boy, if we could all live knowing that when we pass, that’s the reaction. My God, she’s a saint.”
I’VE NEVER MET A STRANGER
Parton’s reach, for St. James, runs well past music and into business.
“Think of the businesses, even from something small like cake mixes and food to Dollywood,” she says. “She has her own amusement park. Who else has their own amusement park on the planet? I was thinking, why isn’t somebody making an Elvis World in Memphis? But she did it, and she’s got resorts. I was just looking, because I’m thinking maybe I need to go to Dollywood now. You can actually stay in her 1986 travel motor coach, all decked out. I’m sure it’s an exorbitant price, but she’s just really iconic.”
Parton’s staying power is the other thing St. James keeps returning to.
“Her popularity never waned. Most people go up and down and up. She was just Dolly, and you didn’t hear a bad word about Dolly,” she says. “I almost took her for granted because she seemed like she was doing it so effortlessly. Even when I’m doing things like this, there’s an energy exchange. Even when I’m talking to fans, there’s a level of being up and being engaged that you have to be. She was always put together, polished, always up. I don’t think we should dismiss how much energy that takes when you are dealing with all kinds of people. She often said, ‘I’ve never met a stranger.’ I really think that’s how she lived her life.”
The money is the last piece.
“I think she did get down. I think her songwriting helped her. But the brilliance of her as a business person, not letting other people run her money,” St. James says. “She could have been a billionaire. I don’t think she crossed that threshold, but she probably didn’t because she gave so much away in philanthropy. And she didn’t flaunt it. She was very careful with her money. I just saw an interview where she said, ‘Yeah, I have accountants, I have business managers, but I watch my money. I watch it all.’”

DON’T YOU LOOK NICE
St. James met William Shatner when he was 93, and she keeps a picture from the encounter.
“He was one of my first crushes as a girl,” she says. “James T. Kirk was a man. That was masculinity. He didn’t know who I was, of course, but he looked me up and down, not in a weird way, and he goes, ‘Well, don’t you look nice.’ Of all the compliments I get from fans, and that’s great, to be acknowledged and told that I looked nice or lovely, I got a compliment from William Shatner. That was just a thrill. And he was 93 years old.”
“Attitude is everything. He has a remarkable energy and zest for life,” she says. “Why is he still out there doing it? Because he’s curious, and he has a love of life. That came through.”
Her own fans have a theory about her taste.
“My fans are like, ‘Oh, you only like young guys.’ And I’m like, no, that’s actually not true. That’s part of what I do. Because I’m a certain age, that’s what my fans like to see. That’s part of the fantasy,” she says. “But it’s really about energy and who the person is. I met William Shatner at 93, and I was like, ‘Oh yeah, he’s still got it.’ The glint in his eye was still there. I think he’s married or partnered up, but would I be interested in a guy like that? Yes.”
“It’s not really about age, but what a wonderful beacon of what life can be at 95. He’s still making plans. In 2027 he’s gonna be on a cruise, he’s gonna do this, he’s gonna do that,” she says. “That’s probably why he’s 95, and he’s still sharp.”
YOUTUBERS, STREAMERS AND MICRO FAME
St. James has a son who is nearly an adult, and he has given her a close look at how celebrity works for a new generation.
“I’m a mom, so I’ve got a kiddo that’s not yet a full adult, but he’s getting there,” she says. “So I get that benefit of seeing how Generation Z thinks. What I noticed with him growing up is celebrity is different for him. He doesn’t really know as many musical acts. I was just talking to a friend of mine in the business, quite a bit younger than I am, and we were talking about Johnny Cash. We both had crushes on him really early. My kid just didn’t know names of actors or musicians. It just wasn’t his thing. But YouTubers and streamers, those are their celebrities.”
The generation gap has a bigger example.
“My kid didn’t know who Oprah Winfrey was. She was the pinnacle of power in the entertainment business for decades, and he had no idea who she was,” she says. “I think about people like that. I had huge crushes on Eric Estrada and Duran Duran or Spandau Ballet. They were just huge at some point. And now what are they doing? I don’t know.”
Her own fame, she says, sits somewhere far down the alphabet.
“I always say I’m micro famous. You’ve got A, B, C, D, and I’m down there. I’ve been recognized in public, and fans have said, ‘Oh, I saw you,’ but it’s very, very different,” she says. “What I will say is it’s that old saying, as above, so below. I relate more to celebrities than I ever did. I have worked really hard. Yes, I’ve used publicists, but the majority of the publicity I’ve gotten has been because of me. I had a concept of a story that I thought would be compelling, so I got myself into Business Insider, which went viral. That was my first big one. I got myself into People magazine last year, USA Today. A lot of those I got myself into first, and I started having a list of very remarkable mainstream media.”
THE PERSONA IS VERY MUCH ME
The name on all of it is a brand she built on purpose.
“It’s all been the branding, and the concept of who Elaina St. James is, and being consistent,” she says. “I remember watching Donnie Deutsches, The Big Idea. I remember the takeaways when I was creating this persona. The persona is very much me, it’s kind of melded into me now, but I didn’t want to have brand dissonance. I’m always very mindful of what my brand is.”
She has tested the edges of it. She once tried a look with a cowboy hat and cutoff jeans.
“Anytime I go away from what my image is, it falls flat. My fans are like, ‘What the hell is that? Why is Elaina wearing cutoff shorts or a cowboy hat? It’s just not my thing,’” she says. “They see me in more of a classic older-woman look: dresses, skirts, high heels, bikinis, which I can’t wear on Instagram anymore. They’ve told me that’s way too sexual. Social media is absolutely pummeling creators right now, especially curvy creators.”
Fleshlight, the sex-toy brand, is one of the facets she has added.
“I’ve worked really hard to create a brand and different facets of the brand, and getting my own Fleshlight Pro. It’s not a Fleshlight Girl, it’s Fleshlight Pro,” she says. “I have my Venn diagram. I’ve worked with a lot of creators that are real porn stars, but I don’t consider myself a porn star because I’ve never done studio work. So I’m an OnlyFans creator. I’m independent, I’m fiercely independent. I don’t wanna work for studios. I don’t wanna give up control of my image. And I don’t see right now, at least, that it would be lucrative to do a studio, except for the marketing. So that’s a trade-off.”
ONE INSTAGRAM REEL
In 2022 and 2023, a single Instagram reel changed her numbers.
“The hardest thing in this business is that one Instagram reel can go viral. I had that happen in 2022 and 2023, 30 million views in a month or more, and my business skyrocketed,” she says. “It stayed up there for a while. But then all of a sudden Instagram doesn’t like you, or you lose a page, or they shadow-ban you, or you get shadow-banned on X even. I have problems with all social media because they all really don’t like us. Then it can just plummet, and you find yourself having your moods or your self-worth determined by those metrics.”
(A shadow ban quietly limits a page’s reach without telling the creator.)
“If that’s how I’m feeling in my fifties, when I’m a fully formed woman, how dangerous is that if you’re 20 or 25 or 18 or whatever, and you’re not a fully formed person with a sense of yourself? How crushing that must be,” she says. “I think about all the celebrities that turn to drugs or have mental illnesses, and I understand them. Like Matthew Perry from Friends, and his struggles with addiction, and how sad his end was. He had all the money in the world, but it really sounded like his quote-unquote friends were probably just employees.”
Her own version of that has been closer to home.
“If you’re not connected to people, or you become so paranoid that people want something from you, I’ve dealt with that too, even in my little micro-fame thing,” she says. “I’ve dealt with finding out that friends, outside of the business or in the business, are all of a sudden doing things to capitalize on what I know or my connections. It’s been incredibly sad and painful. And I think, God, that’s just me. If you’re a real celebrity, it’s gotta be a whole different level.”

THE NORTH STAR
Asked where her work ethic comes from, St. James answers with her son.
“My main goal in life is to take care of my child, who I had on my own completely,” she says. “That is the North Star. That is everything. I am fiercely protective of him, even though he’s almost an adult. I have two goals in my life: to make enough money that I can retire comfortably, and to leave as much as possible for him. So when I take my last breath, I know he’s gonna be okay. That’s it. There’s nothing else.”
The goal has left little room for anything else.
“Because of that, it’s a very defined thing. How do I make the money? I work hard. I try to figure out how to work smart,” she says. “People ask, what are your hobbies? I used to have a lot of hobbies. I used to do a lot of fun things. That will happen someday, maybe after I’m retired. I like to travel, but I make that travel work with what I’m doing. If I’m traveling someplace, you’re gonna see content made there, not sexy content necessarily, but you’re gonna see me walking around, which a lot of my fans like. Some of them are like, ‘We just wanna see the thirst-trap stuff.’ But I can write it off if I’m making content, and I’m still creating content that I can use. I haven’t taken a day off since I started this, over five and a half years. I have never taken a day off where I’m not either making content or checking my messages on my fan sites.”
Travel brought its own complications.
“A couple of times I almost had panic attacks, and it was on a cruise in the Mediterranean. I made a lot of social media content,” she says. “But even though I had the really expensive wifi, they thought that OnlyFans and Fansly were adult sites, which obviously they are, and I couldn’t get access to them unless I was near an island that had a cell tower. You can’t go down to the wifi people and be like, ‘I am on OnlyFans, I need to get on OnlyFans.’ Even if you did, it wouldn’t help.”
“I learned that the hard way, and I tell other people all the time, if you’re on a cruise, you might not have wifi. Even so, with 24 hours between ports or a day at sea, I made a big announcement to my guys that I wouldn’t be able to answer messages. I was always very conscious of that,” she says. “On those days I’d be on the deck making content. So yeah, I’ve never had a day off, but it’s also so that I can retire and leave as much as possible for my son. There’s nothing more important than that.”
NO TURNER CLASSIC MOVIES FOR PORN
When the talk turned to performers who don’t know who came before them, St. James started with the ones she knows.
“I’m friendly with Lisa Ann, and I filmed with Christie Canyon and at the time also met Ginger,” she says. “They’re wonderful, but their energy is probably what I would expect rock stars to be like. They’re just on and wonderful.”
“I don’t know much about the adult industry except for what has crossed into mainstream. It’s harder because of the difference with the golden ages of the 80s and 90s. That was DVDs, a different production,” she says. “I talked to Christie and Ginger about what that was like. The people who are foremost now, in their 20s and 30s, are just digital. They’ve always been digital. They don’t know about DVDs or VHS. It probably seems like ancient times.”
Her son supplied the comparison.
“It’s like when my kid was little and he looked at a Model T and said, ‘That car looks like it’s from the 80s.’ I’m like, it’s a freaking Model T. That’s from the 1920s,” she says. “But that’s the mindset. It’s so foreign because it was such a different platform. And it’s so underground too. It’s not like the classics channels, right? There’s no Turner Classic Movies for porn, any place.”
A SMALLER POND
On why the MILF niche has never waned, St. James has a theory, and a complaint about the label’s lower age limit.
“As a mature MILF, I’m verging very closely to the GILF thing, but I’m not ready to embrace the GILF yet,” she says. “I’m just not there. I think the MILF thing is the taboo of being an older woman, hands off. When men came into their sexuality, what are the women around? They’re probably their friends’ moms and teachers and other older women. It comes so early. It’s so hardwired into them. Obviously it’s not all men. The funniest thing about the MILF thing is you’ve got some gals who are 22. I get it, you can be a mom at 22, obviously. But come on, at least be 35 to be a MILF.”
(GILF is the grandmother version of the label.)
“Sometimes I have issues with that. I entered this five and a half years ago already as a mature MILF, and I’m okay with that,” she says. “It’s a smaller pond. I can be a bigger fish in a smaller pond.”
She has also heard from the other end of the age range.
“I’ve heard of some younger creators that are sad that they’re not old enough yet, that they’re just hot girls. I remember a discussion with a very hot, beautiful adult actress who’s gotten a lot of notoriety. I won’t name-drop her,” she says. “She said, ‘What have I got?’ And I said, ‘Well, you’re funny. You’re not just a hot girl, you’re funny. Lean into that. You’ve got really good comedic timing in a very dry sense.’”
BIG BOOBS AND A SMILE
“I don’t remember the MILF thing from when I was growing up, except for Mrs. Robinson,” St. James says. “When I was young it was Farrah Fawcett, Cheryl Teague, Christie Brinkley. They were all young and beautiful and perfect and blonde. That was the epitome of beauty. So I’m grateful, my God, I’m grateful for the MILF thing.”
She did not start out in it.
“I got into this thinking I was gonna be a totally different type of creator. I didn’t even realize the MILF thing was that big. I thought I was gonna be more like a dominatrix. I thought that would be my little niche,” she says. “What was refreshing was the niche my fans told me I was. They said, ‘No, you’re mom next door. You’re MILF. You’re just straight-up mom next door, Midwest mom, nice and smiles.’”
The brand got its shortest description on Holly Randall’s show.
“Holly Randall asked me, ‘Elaina, what’s your brand?’” she says. “And I said, really, if it boils down to it, it’s big boobs and a smile. That’s my brand.”

I’M NOT GONNA CALL ANYBODY DADDY
One fan wanted a nickname.
“I remember one guy who said, ‘Hey, when we talk, can you call me daddy?’ And I’m like, no. If my dad was alive at 85, that’s just weird,” she says. “I’m not gonna call anybody daddy. I don’t like to be judgmental, but when I see these way older MILFs calling a guy who’s maybe 10, 20 years younger daddy, I don’t know, it’s strange to me. The whole age thing is so weird.”
The age range of her audience surprised her from the start.
“When I got my first two subscribers, it was a 28-year-old and a 29-year-old. I was flabbergasted. I had no idea that I would appeal to much younger men,” she says. “I really asked them a lot of questions. I was like, ‘Aren’t you interested in a hot 25-year-old?’ No, no. They were like, ‘You’re a MILF, and this is what you’ve got going for you.’”
The name came before the brand did.
“If I had known what my brand was gonna be, I would have branded my name differently. Ellie or Elle or something, not so formal and high-end. It would have been much more approachable,” she says. “But it morphed into something that was actually more achievable long-term and much more available to the mainstream. If I would have stuck with a dominatrix thing, and I’ve seen other gals in this business who are very much dominatrix, they are limited on the media they can get. They are limited in so many ways. I’m much more open.”
GENUINE AND AUTHENTIC
Pressed on why fans who joined five years ago are still with her, St. James is brief.
“They see me more like a human,” she says. “Because I’m genuine and because I’m authentic.”
Every Friday morning, a new chat video goes up for her OnlyFans subscribers.
“It used to be chat and flash, but basically it’s a weekly video. It’s pre-recorded, but timely, or try-ons, and I just talk for about 10 or 15 minutes: okay, this is what happened,” she says. “I bought a house, and there’s been all kinds of wacky stuff I’ve had to deal with. I don’t get specific, so they couldn’t find me or anything like that. But I’m naked and I’m touching myself, not sexually, just chatting, and I start talking about downspouts. I am a total nerd about downspouts. Getting the water away, and doing the L brackets, and pop-ups. Have you guys ever heard about these pop-ups that open when the drain comes?”
The fans wrote back.
“I had so many fans send me messages: ‘You crack me up. You’re talking about a new scene you just did, and then you switch into talking about downspouts and how you’re gonna have to move them.’ But they love it because it’s real,” she says. “Sometimes I’m frustrated about something, or something funny happened. I get very real, and I don’t think a lot of creators do that. They just act like they’re horny all the time.”
WOMEN ARE WOMEN
“I’ll tell guys, listen, women are women,” she says. “I don’t think there are many women who don’t have a medical or mental issue who are walking around like horn dogs all the time. That’s not how women operate. I also don’t really appreciate when other creators are always like, ‘Show me your dick, show me your dick.’ Most women don’t feel that way, and I think it’s disingenuous. I think it’s setting some men up to do dumb things in their personal lives. So I don’t do that.”
Her own policy on unsolicited photos is plain.
“I’m like, listen, your dick is great. It’s attached to you. If it works, if it’s good, accept it. But I’m not gonna act like an unsolicited dick pic is gonna turn me into a raging horn dog. It’s not gonna happen, because I’m a regular woman,” she says. “I’ll say, ‘You should probably clean that up a little bit,’ or ‘You should pick up your room because it’s a mess.’ That’s what women look for when you send a dick pic. We’re gonna look at everything else, because we’re women.”
“You might get turned on by my boob or my other private parts because you’re a guy. But it’s disingenuous if I’m acting like you sending me a dick pic is going to elicit a strong sexual response from me,” she says. “Maybe that’s because I’m a mom. I don’t want these guys to go out in the real world and think that women are gonna be like, ‘Oh, a dick pic, I love it.’ No.”
LINES I NEVER THOUGHT I’D CROSS
St. James has been single the whole time she has done this work, and she says that shaped what she expected of herself.
“There are some lines I know I would never cross. There are gray lines. There are lines that I have crossed,” she says. “Because I’m single, and I have been single this whole time, I never thought I would do real sex. I was very comfortable with the masturbation, those kinds of things, in the privacy and safety of my home. I never ever thought that I would have sex with somebody else on camera. But for a year I contemplated it. First of all, fans demanded it. I was like, I’m solo, I’m solo, I’m solo. If I was married, yes, I would do it. How do I do that?”
What changed her mind was the market.
“After a year of talking to other creators and seeing that solo creators were dropping off, and I saw that start happening in 2022, solo creators couldn’t make it. They could make it during COVID, but they were struggling because of the expectation of fans that there would be more,” she says. “More and more solo creators, maybe they weren’t full nude or whatever, just started dropping off because they couldn’t make it financially. I talked to so many of my friends and they’re like, ‘Yeah, that’s where the money is.’ So that’s something I never thought I would do. And then the group stuff, which is not my forte. I have no interest in a gangbang. To me, that’s just crazy.”
I’M NOT IN THE SLUT OLYMPICS
St. James says she is not interested in anal sex on camera, and a conversation with Christie Canyon on the subject has stayed with her.
“Christie said something really funny once when we were talking about it. She looked at me as if I asked a crazy question,” she says. “This is my response now to fans. She’ll be like, ‘Why do I need to do anal? I have big natural boobs.’ Period. That was her answer. I don’t know if that was just her, or if maybe back in the day that was the thing: ‘I don’t need to do that.’ I thought it was hilarious, because that’s an answer, and I’m used to that answer.”
“I’ll let other people do that. I have said this a lot: I am not in the Slut Olympics,” she says. “I bring something else to the table. I don’t have to do these crazy stunts. Bless her heart, Bonnie Blue, my God. She is an icon just because of her crazy stunt stuff. That’s not for me.”
She does have a group scene on the way.
“I’m about to release a male, female, male, female that I did with another MILF creator. Maybe two guys at some point,” she says. “They’d have to be guys that I feel comfortable with, that I know, a couple of creators I’ve worked with before. I just filmed an interracial scene, and he was very sweet. It was a really interesting experience, but the group dynamic is out of my comfort zone, especially when they’re not studio trained.”

THE STUDIO GUYS
The foursome is due out that Friday, and the shoot taught her a difference.
“I really appreciate working with adult actors that are studio trained. That is one revelation,” she says. “That’s the big demarcation I found. It was, oh boy, this is really different. With the studio guys, with Lucas Frost, Ryan Driller, Jay Smooth, Max Fills, Tyler Cruz, Jimmy Michaels, I sit down and I’m basically a director. I’m like, ‘Okay, so I want to do this.’ They know all the positions. They know how to open for the camera. They know how to get aroused, stay aroused and pop when needed. When you’re dealing with amateurs or semi-pros, it’s a different dynamic. I really decided I appreciate working with professionals.”
“I think the next thing I want to do, and this is not easy, and maybe you have some suggestions, is work with somebody close to my own age,” she says. “I don’t think there’s anybody older than me who’s well known. Men really age out in this industry.”
I LOOK ATTAINABLE
Her fans like to think she is having a good time, and she says she is.
“One of the things my guys love is I have real orgasms when I film. Not always. There’s a couple of videos where I haven’t,” she says. “But the majority of all my solo and my real sex, I’m having actual orgasms. For me, honestly, I’m celibate other than being in front of the camera, so I might as well, especially when I’m dealing with a fun, hot guy.”
“The reason that OnlyFans creators are successful is that we look attainable. We’re not perfect. Studio gals are perfect, there’s a perfection to their bodies,” she says. “OnlyFans creators are successful because they look like somebody you could get in real life. From the back end, I talk to creators often, and I’m like, they’ve bought into the sauce. They really think that they are supermodels, because they’ve been incredibly successful. I’m not shaming them, but there’s a humility they don’t realize. I’m not a 10. I’ve never been a 10. I look attainable. I have cellulite. My boobs aren’t perfect, one’s bigger than the other. That’s part of why I’m successful. A lot of the MILFs I talk to don’t realize that. It’s a very strange dynamic.”
The dad-bod look is a popular niche right now, but casting it is another matter.
“Because my dynamic is such an age thing, a lot of times they don’t mind seeing a guy that’s in great shape,” she says. “It’s not easy to find a guy that is more of a dad bod, because these guys have to be such sexual athletes. It’s like saying, ‘I’d like to find a dad bod who’s a basketball player.’ God, it’s hard, because their job requires them to be so physically fit. It’s tough for a male performer to not be physically fit.”
STRAIGHT WOMEN BUY LOVE
“I was not a big porn or adult connoisseur,” she says. “I’m a straight woman of a certain age, and we don’t really consume porn. All these guys are like, ‘I would love to be a content creator. I want to rate boobs.’ And I’m like, you are going to live in a box down by the river. I never say never, but you’re not going to make a living on women paying to rate their boobs, because that’s how we live. If we want to have our boobs rated, I can go next door. That guy will rate my boobs. I can go to any place on the planet. Nobody’s going to pay for it.”
“Straight women for the most part do not buy adult entertainment. We buy love, we buy romance. That is our entertainment. So guys that want to cater to a woman, it’s a different dynamic,” she says. “I’ve told the guys, if you want to be a content creator as a man, you better cater to a male audience, because that’s who’s going to pay. You’re not going to get straight women spending money on that unless you’re bringing some kind of romantic thing.”
WHAT THE HELL?
“I didn’t watch adult entertainment, so it was a shock to me when I saw all this rough stuff,” she says. “I didn’t understand it. Or the word facial. I had never heard of that. The facial, the choking, the slapping, the hair pulling. I’m like, what the hell?”
On her first online scene with a very well-known performer, she had to set the terms in the moment.
“At one point he put his hand, I think it was just muscle memory, and I was like, uh-uh. I took his hand away. But it’s obviously so endemic in the industry,” she says. “I’ve talked to some people about that and they’re like, ‘Well, yeah, you just need to ramp it up and ramp it up.’ And I’m like, God, I don’t play that game. Am I leaving money on the table? I suppose. But there are just some things I won’t do, and I’m not going to put my body through that.”
“It does worry me, because I know a lot of guys learn about how to treat women romantically from watching adult entertainment. That is a huge concern of mine,” she says. “As a mom, as a human being, as a woman.”
Age comes into it, too.
“Once you have more agency as a woman, for the most part, as you get older, you can set boundaries. I’ve heard some people, I think it was Sheri Deville and Holly Randall, talking about the age thing, and I think a lot of women in this industry look at it,” she says. “I’ve heard a lot of women talk about 25 being the starting point. I wouldn’t disagree. There’s so much that goes into this industry that I’m glad I was a grown-up who had lived a life before I got into this.”
THE PEANUT BUTTER THAT WAS 20 CENTS CHEAPER
On consistency, St. James says she doesn’t even think about it.
“It’s what I do, as a responsible human being,” she says. “I don’t pay a lot of attention to other creators, but fans have told me, ‘This girl uploads maybe once a week, or it’ll be a couple of weeks before she uploads something.’ For me, I plan it. I’ve got pictures and video clips until, I think, near the end of December. I always think, if I died, my page could still kind of maintain itself, because I’ve got my PPV going out on a rotation. I use a system.”
(PPV is pay-per-view content sold to subscribers on top of the monthly fee.)
“I just don’t ever want my fans to subscribe to my fan sites and not think they’re getting a lot of value for their dollar. It all goes back to this: I was raised poor,” she says. “We were on the low side of working poor, and I’ve been poor. There were times I made so little that I could qualify for food stamps. I’ve been in places that are really scary financially. There were times I looked at peanut butter and went, ‘Oh, I have to buy the one that’s 20 cents cheaper.’”
“Because of that, I don’t want to rip anyone off. I’ll tell them, adult is not a necessity, it’s a luxury, and maybe you can’t afford this right now,” she says. “Usually I’ve got a deal going for new subscribers, $5, or if they come back. Otherwise it’s $10 a month. But I want to make sure they always feel like they got their $10 worth.”
IT’S WHAT THE FAN WANTS
“Of course I edit my own videos, so I have to look at them through that lens,” she says. “There’s one I won’t name, and boy, that was tough. We had to leave, and he had to get something to rev up again. He was a really nice guy, it just wasn’t working for him. Once that happened, it was fine. But I’ve never heard any fan mention it. They’re like, ‘Great scene, great scene.’ They couldn’t tell the difference.”
Her favorites and her fans’ favorites do not always match.
“There are some scenes I liked more and some co-stars I liked more than others. It’s what the fan wants,” she says. “If they’re into the age-gap thing, or into BBC, it doesn’t matter how much enjoyment I’m having or whether I looked happy or not. They were into that. There’s one creator who’s always my favorite, because we have such a good connection. Some of my fans can tell. They’ll be like, ‘Oh my God, your face, you’re melting. You were just like a puddle.’ And I’m like, yes.”
“A lot of times they’ll ask, ‘What’s your best video?’ I’ll say it’s this one, and then I’ll ask, ‘What do you want to order?’ and they’ll go with something else,” she says. “I never say what my best video is, because it doesn’t matter what I think. It’s what they’re into. You want to see my hardest orgasm? It’s this one. But if you’re not into that, you’re still going to go with whatever you’re into.”
She shoots a lot of softcore on purpose.
“People are like, ‘Why would you do that?’ Multiple reasons. The main thing is marketing,” she says. “The other thing is they get to see you do it, but they don’t get to see it. So if they want to see it, they pay.”
Some fans complain about the production.
“Once in a while I’ll get guys who say, ‘Your production value could be better, the lighting, the angles.’ And I’m like, but that’s not what you’re paying for. You’re paying for a brand,” she says. “If you want that, there’s Brazzers, there’s Vixen, there’s all kinds of those things. You can get all of those.”

FIFTY SHADES OF ELAINA
With male co-stars, she does an interview on camera first.
“I like to interview them beforehand. I like to chit-chat with them for real,” she says. “I’m always amused, especially with the studio guys, because they have great stories. I usually tease them, because it sets up a rapport, which is sexy. It’s the foreplay. There was one time, I think it was Will Ponder, during the little sexy chit-chat, he was talking about a reverse gangbang. I might be wrong, but I think it was more than five. I think he said 11 girls. And I was like, what? How does that even work? Are four of them in the other room making sandwiches? Just physically, there’s not enough of you for 11 people.”
One of those conversations turned into a scene. Ryan Driller had told her about a Fifty Shades of Grey parody he worked on that was released and then pulled.
“It was my idea, because when we first filmed together, he told me he had been part of a production for the parody of Fifty Shades of Grey. It got released and then rescinded because they got in trouble legally,” she says. “He was telling me how cool this production was and how they even had a helicopter. That stuck with me, because I was a huge fan of that genre. I said, ‘When we film together next, I want to do Fifty Shades of Elaina.’ I’ll be the older woman, aggressive, assertive. You’re gonna be assertive too, but then I ultimately dominate you and take over. That was really fun. We did an after where we talked about it, and he talked about the process.”
“I like teasing these adult stars because it’s just fun to me,” she says. “Jimmy Michaels played Elf on the Shelf in one of his videos. That cracked me up so much that I had to ask him about it on camera before a scene. I said, ‘Walk me through how that worked.’ He’s describing it and I’m cracking up, because that is so awesome and absurd. The whole scenario, I just found it so fun and funny.”
Tyler Cruz had an answer ready for a different question.
“I asked Tyler Cruz, ‘So how many MILFs have you filmed with?’ And he goes, ‘You know what? A lot,’” she says. “‘There are probably fewer MILFs you can name that I haven’t filmed with than I have.’ I love hearing that, because that’s my little Venn diagram of being a content creator independently, just a normal woman, and then getting in touch with this whole adult entertainment world, which is like a mini hidden Hollywood.”
“I love giving that experience to my fans, to get to know them as human beings. Unless they’re watching an actual interview, it’s not going to be the same, because I’m teasing them. They know we’re gonna film right afterwards,” she says. “There’s a different dynamic, and I don’t think enough creators do that. They don’t make it interesting. They don’t give you the tease. I never hear complaints like, ‘Elaina, you talked too much before.’ They like it. It adds something different.”
LET THERE BE A LITTLE LEAD-UP
“The other thing my fans love is I laugh. I giggle while having sex,” she says. “They say, ‘It makes me feel good. You’re not being roughed up. Nobody’s calling you names.’ I can literally get turned on, do what I need to do, and feel good about it. I feel lighter and happier because it’s so natural. You do laugh when you’re having sex in real life. You’re laughing and talking and trying to figure things out. It’s not all this performative moaning and groaning and yelling and craziness. That’s what my guys love. It’s feel-good and happy and fun.”
Customs, the personalized videos fans pay for, get the same treatment.
“If somebody hires me to do a 15-minute custom, I’m like, ‘Okay, we’re basically gonna do a six-minute striptease.’ And they’re like, ‘Six minutes? How is that possible?’” she says. “I’m like, if you do six minutes, you’ve just saved four minutes of more wear and tear on your body.”
“I think there have been studies about when people in real life have sex and how long actual penetration lasts, compared to how much you’re going to make out, hopefully,” she says. “It goes back to being disingenuous, and doing the right thing as far as portraying more real life. If a man wants to be happy, he’s gonna put in the time to warm up a woman, and everything’s gonna be better. It might just be, you talk to her for a while, or you make out, or you massage her back a little bit. Let there be a little bit of a lead-up.”
KEEPING IT REAL
On whether a creator owes viewers a reminder that it is all fantasy, St. James answers by scene.
“Role play is obviously a fantasy. But honestly, I try to keep it as real as possible, because I’m not performative,” she says. “I know I’ve got to do the different positions, and those things are going through my head, but I try to make it more real, for the most part. It’s easier when it’s a tripod and a guy and me. The harder ones are when you’ve got a camera person there, or it’s multiple people.”
One group scene had a cameraman.
“I had never been in a group scene, and the guy was holding the camera. He starts giggling, because he must have read it on my face: ‘Oh Jesus, look at this,’” she says. “He just starts laughing, panned right to me, and probably caught the ‘Wow.’”
The role play, she says, is a different thing.
“Yes, I’ll do the role play. My girlfriend’s mom, or the few I’ve done, a couple of the stepmom or step-aunt, that kind of stuff. Then I have to pretend and we play-act,” she says. “I would never do any of that in my real life, clearly. That’s an act. But the actual sex stuff, I try to keep real, because I don’t want it to be performative. I’ve seen women who are so performative that it’s off-putting. I’m like, what is she doing? That’s crazy. And then I start thinking, do women really do that? That’s an act.”
As for how far the step-relative genre has stretched, she keeps her record clear. “I haven’t done the step-monkey,” she says.
Her rules are set before the cameras roll.
“I don’t do any of that just because I don’t like it. I always tell guys before, ‘Listen, we don’t do rough stuff.’ With the professional actors, I’m always like, ‘This should be a pretty easy shoot for you,’” she says. “I’m in my fifties and I’m not gonna do any aerobics. You’re not gonna have to put out a lot of effort, because that’s not what my guys expect. They don’t expect me to get a big workout, and thank God, because I don’t want to.”
VACATION DICK AND BOYFRIEND DICK
“Let’s face it, most women, even adult actresses, and there are a couple of things I’ve noticed when I watch women be interviewed, probably 90% don’t like overly large penises. They don’t want it,” she says. “Especially if they’re super long, they get pokey, right? And they don’t want guys to be super rough. I think there’s a time and place, but the size is something that messes with guys. They’re like, ‘Oh, I’m only this big.’ I’ll reassure them, and they’ll listen.”
“I’ve heard even women in the industry say, ‘There’s vacation dick, and then there’s boyfriend dick.’ You don’t want a vacation dick every day. That’s hard,” she says. “It’s almost a disability in a way, because there are a lot of women for whom that’s a turn-off. And yet in our culture, it’s really weird that guys still think that having a really giant penis is some great thing. I don’t know of any woman, even in the industry, walking around going, ‘Oh, yes, giant penis.’ It’s the guy attached. It’s always going to be the guy attached.”
“A guy that can go down on a woman and please her, and be reliable in life, and help her and make her feel good about herself, 10 times out of 10, most women are gonna want that guy over a guy who just has a really big penis,” she says.
Some guys push back on the other side.
“They’ll say, ‘Yeah, but every guy you’ve filmed with has a decently long penis.’ And I’m like, they have to,” she says. “In adult entertainment you actually have to see the movement happening, and that’s why guys have to have a certain length. In real life, nobody’s saying that.”
WHAT MAKES US LOVABLE
“What makes us not perfect, what makes us vulnerable, makes us lovable,” she says. “We fall in love with people because of their vulnerability and because we see something in them that goes beyond the shell of who they are. When you see a perfect woman or a perfect man next to somebody who’s not as perfect, it’s probably because they saw something in each other that went beyond just the looks.”
A documentary has been on her mind.
“It’s a really interesting documentary with Louis Theroux called The Manosphere. It’s all about the influencers that are the manly men, like the Tate brothers and some others at lower levels who are flaunting their riches and their rented cars and rented houses,” she says. “It’s the bro culture. I think we’re fighting some of that in this industry too, because those are the same guys who want to marginalize women, who want to look at them as property, as things. We’re fighting that now more than ever. And I think they do a major disservice to men in general.”

A GROWN-UP WOMAN
On how long it took to settle into her brand and her age, St. James says it took a few months.
“I started when I was 54. I realized very quickly, in the first couple of months, that this dominant thing is not gonna work. That’s okay, because it’s easier for me to be just more naturally who I am,” she says. “So I leaned into that, and I never backed away from the age. I know a lot of women lie about their age in this industry. I never did, because I always knew, just as a business and marketing matter, that whatever makes you different makes you special, and you can lean into it.”
Her audience has aged with her.
“When I was in my mid-fifties, I was attracting much more of the younger guys in their 20s. There has been a turn. A lot of my fans are getting older now, and that’s fine,” she says. “Now that I’m approaching 60, next year I’ll be 60, and I don’t lie about my age, I’ve gotten fewer of the young guys and more of the older guys. It’s totally fine. One of the things I love about my older fans is they’ll say, ‘Thank God you’re here, because I don’t feel like a weird creep looking at a 25-year-old. I can look at you at 55 myself, or 65 or 70.’”
The oldest fan she knows of is 79.
“He said, ‘I don’t wanna look at a 25-year-old having sex. It’s gross. It’s my granddaughter’s age. I wanna see a grown-up woman, and you let me feel that sexuality and that sensuality, and I don’t have to feel weird about it,’” she says.
The next age bracket has a narrower audience.
“I don’t think there are many women who go past my age. In the studio, of course there’s not. I think there’s the GILF, but the GILF age really shrinks down your audience a lot,” she says. “There’s the mature MILF, and once you cross over, there might be a bigger part of the pie, but the pie is much smaller as far as guys who are interested in the GILF thing. I’ve been playing with this Elaina Silver. I have a couple of silver wigs and I play with that on social media. I have some of that content on my regular page, and it’s a mixed bag. Some guys are like, ‘Don’t do it. Don’t go gray, don’t go silver.’ And some guys are like, ‘Super hot. Oh my God, that’s fantastic.’”
Some of her fans want to see her with someone nearer her own age.
“I’m like, who? I know of one adult male actor who is my age and is still performing, and that is a known name,” she says. “Being an adult actor as a male is incredibly hard. It’s incredibly difficult. I wouldn’t want anybody to try to do that, because I’ve heard stories of guys on set at 28 years old shooting up.”
“Obviously a lot of women retire, just because it’s not just hard on your body, it’s hard to be aging on camera,” she says. “I gotta tell you, sometimes I’m like, ‘Oh, that looks pretty good.’ But sometimes I’m like, ‘Oh my God.’”
THE RUG PULL
“I guess that’s one of the advantages that I have, because I know why I’m here,” she says. “I know what I do. It’s very clear. So it kind of structures everything. I think that’s one of the challenges you see with Hollywood. I see how that happens, but for us, I think it’s really more the social media.”
Her mornings start with a held breath.
“I open up my phone and I catch my breath before I even let Instagram load. Because I’m like, is today gonna be a restriction? Am I gonna lose an account? Am I gonna have to pay to get an account back? Am I gonna have a dud? Am I gonna be shadow-banned?” she says. “And it’s fricking YouTube. YouTube has taken me to the core. How can I, as a woman, not be seen in a swimming suit on a beach? They have a problem with that. A one-piece, they have a problem with that. When some women are wearing sheer stuff where I can see everything, it’s the inconsistency.”
“You never know when the rug pull is gonna be with social media. And it’s every stupid platform. It’s stupid Reddit and all their moderators,” she says. “I was on Bluesky and I got off Bluesky because some of those liberal women were just horrible. I’m kind of middle of the ground politically. You got the churchy ones, they’re horrible, too.”
Substack was the most recent surprise.
“Somebody just recently attacked me on Substack about how they were gonna report me. I was fully clothed. I was never even wearing swimsuits on Substack. I see almost nudity or semi-nudity on Substack. I was very PG on everything,” she says. “And they’re like, ‘We don’t need that smut here. This is not the format for this.’ And I’m like, well, I have written two books. They’re on Amazon. I’ve written an article on Substack and I plan on writing more. I didn’t think that Substack was for kids. You’re supposed to be over 18.”
WHACK-A-MOLE
“You get the trolls. And then there are impostors and leaked content. We’re getting hit every which way, from every place,” she says. “We’re constantly on the edge of disaster happening.”
A friend of hers recently fell for a scam that is going around the industry.
“Somehow they got ahold of her email. She was sent a link that said, ‘You are about to be deactivated by OnlyFans. Click this link to appeal.’ It was late at night. She wasn’t thinking straight. She clicked it because she panicked,” she says. “It was on Friday night, which also, because OnlyFans doesn’t have customer service over the weekend usually.”
Her own accounts are under constant attack.
“I just hired back Take Down Piracy to start finding leaked content. They’re like, ‘Oh my God, we are finding thousands and thousands and thousands of things,’ and they’re taking them down,” she says. “It’s like whack-a-mole to some degree. And then we have to deal with impostors. I’ve still got one on Facebook that’s got a link to X-rated stuff. I keep reporting it, and it’s still up. It’s Elaina St. James, and they’re using all my old reels. It links to stolen content. And I’m just like, how can I not get this down?”
NOBODY TALKS TO ME ANYMORE
“The big difference is social media likes regular entertainers. They hate us. That’s probably one of the biggest problems, psychologically,” she says. “Not only that, it’s the stigma of never feeling like you can tell anybody in real life what you do, because you’re just waiting to be judged. I’ve lost all my family. Nobody talks to me anymore, which is horrible, because that also means my kid has lost family. I didn’t think that would happen. I thought I had an open-minded family, but they’re not.”
“Even friends that were not in the industry, for different reasons, fell away. It’s so hard to make friends as an adult, and even when you’re friendly like I am, it’s hard,” she says. “Then to know in the back of your head, ‘God, if they find out what I do, they’re gonna be gone.’ A lot of those people, from my experience, if you’re upfront about stuff, that goes away pretty quick.”
She has a view on the ones who don’t stay.
“It’s when people deny and people lie, ‘Oh, that’s not me. I don’t know what you’re talking about,’ that they’re looking for a fight,” she says. “When I get an argument, if I don’t agree with something, I’m not gonna argue with you, because it validates a point I don’t agree with. I’ve seen it happen when I’ve told people the truth. I’ve seen people give me a horrified look, and then I never talk to them again.”
SHE CAN DO IT ALL
When the talk turned to AI, St. James had a history to share.
“I have a lot of feelings about AI, backed with my experience,” she says. “I was an early adopter, thinking that AI was really going to be a good thing, that I could use my image, and I could be Elaina St. James at 55 forever. I signed up with a company, Forever Companion, Forever Voices, who were the first ones. They came out with this Karen AI. They got a lot of publicity with Bloomberg TV, lots of coverage. And then it failed spectacularly before they did anything.”
“My whole thing for years was, wow, once they can make content, they can make content with other creators and I don’t even have to be there,” she says. “My AI can do gangbangs. She’s a slut, she can do it all. I don’t care. It’s not my physical body. I can safely be sipping coffee and she can do all this crazy stuff.”
She signed with a couple more companies, and she is still with one.
“Here’s my honest assessment. They have all these promises. Our whole economy is propped up by AI, thinking that AI is going to do everything,” she says. “I gotta tell you, I believe it’s gonna be an AI bubble, and it’s gonna pop, just like it did in ’99.”
WHERE’S THE MARKET?
“I think we’re seeing the cracks. These seven guys or so in tech have propped it up as the unicorn, the amazing AI that’s going to do everything,” she says. “In reality, and I think this is for chatbots, guys don’t want it. There’s no market. It’s not profitable. That’s the bottom line. Nobody wants to admit that, but there’s not a freaking market for it. You can build a spaceship to go to Venus, but if nobody wants to go on it, that’s a waste of money.”
Her own fans have weighed in.
“I have propped up all of these chatbots that have my Elaina AI. I’ve done a lot of marketing for it. I’ve pushed guys,” she says. “And you know what? My fans go on there and they go, ‘It was okay. It was novel. I played with it for a little bit, but I’d rather talk to the real you. Why would I spend my money there?’ That’s the bottom line. Everyone thinks there’s a big market for AI adult. There’s not.”
“I don’t hear any guys say that, though obviously maybe they wouldn’t be on my site. I know somebody who’s Gen Z, and he’s not interested in it,” she says. “I think there’s the anime stuff, the weird stuff with tentacles. I think there’s a place for that. But if you’re attracted to Elaina St. James, you want to talk to Elaina St. James, not Elaina AI. Guys don’t want to put their money and time there. There are some, but not as many as want the real experience of talking to a real creator they know is a real human being. It’s the authenticity they like.”
Three years ago, she says, she would have answered differently.
“I would have said it’s just the image of me being with that. Now I have flipped on what I think about AI with erotic entertainment. I don’t see there’s a market for it, because if they know it’s not real, and I don’t know if in my lifetime we’re ever going to make it so realistic that it’s indistinguishable, I think morally we have to say if it’s AI or not,” she says. “And as a creator I think, wait a second. Do I really want somebody else to have full control, making videos with my image? What if they do it and I’m with a donkey or something? I don’t want that. That’s scary. Maybe I’d be okay with a five-man gangbang with AI, but I’m not okay with this. So that makes it less appealing.”
GARBAGE IN, GARBAGE OUT
“I think a lot of these companies are being so propped up by investors. I don’t think they’re letting creators know how little they’re actually making, and then they go defunct, or they keep promising these great innovations and it never happens,” she says. “I’ve worked with like five of these companies, and I’m like, ‘What’s going on with this that you said was going to be ready in a couple of months?’ ‘Oh, it’s just not there yet.’ Or, ‘We’ll go on a call.’ ‘Okay, great. Can you show me how this feature that you said was working?’”
“I’ll chat with my own AI and I’ll be like, oh my God, the AI just told this guy to go to Instagram for my spicy stuff. What the hell? How are you training this chatbot? If the guy asks for a picture, all of a sudden it’s just a pop-up that says subscribe,” she says. “If you can’t even train the chatbot to chat, how are you going to sell custom photos, custom videos? It’s just poorly done. Maybe it can’t be done, I don’t know.”
“Everyone has these big ideas, and they have huge investors, because you say AI and it’s chumming the water in the tech area, in the business area right now. Anything with AI sells, and it has for the last three or four years,” she says. “They’ve got investors coming out of the wazoo: ‘Oh yeah, adult entertainment with AI, we’re going to make so much money.’ But they haven’t done any market research. Who’s buying it? Is it the incels, the guys that are lonely and don’t have a life? Are they really buying it? Where’s the market? Nobody can ever tell me this. It makes me crazy. They don’t test their own product. I’ve tested it, and this thing just told me to go to Instagram to get my spicy content.”
She uses AI herself, with reservations.
“I use AI sometimes, but I also realize AI is wrong a lot. When I play with ChatGPT and Claude AI, a lot of times I’ll push back, ‘That’s not even accurate.’ ‘Oh, you’re right. You’re right for pushing back on that,’” she says. “Then you’ve got all this AI slop going out on the internet, so now they’re creating information that’s going out and dumbing down what they’re getting. Garbage in, garbage out. Now there’s more garbage created by AI, and they’re feeding off that to train. It’s going to get less effective.”
“I listened to Scott Galloway and Kara Swisher about this tech stuff. Scott Galloway says there’s an AI bubble. It’s going to be useful, but not to the degree the tech bros say it’s going to be useful,” she says. “Look what happened to the Metaverse. How many billions of dollars did Mark Zuckerberg spend on the Metaverse? It’s gone now. Why? There wasn’t a market for it. Nobody wanted it. That’s what they’re going to find. And it’s actually more expensive than hiring real people.”
IT SHOULD ALWAYS BE LABELED
Told that some creators pass AI-generated photos off as real, St. James is blunt.
“I don’t do that. I would always label things. I think that’s gross. I think it’s a breach of trust. I think it should always be labeled,” she says.
“I thought in the beginning, and I really did change my thoughts on it, that it would free me up so I could make those things. I had always thought it would be like, oh yeah, Elaina St. James can be 55 forever. I thought that was cool,” she says. “But I never thought that I would try to fool somebody. To me, it was lazy, getting lazier.”
A LARK THAT KEPT SELLING
Her first book, How to Date Hot Older Women, came out in 2022. She has a copy within reach.
“It was kind of a lark. It was very, very small. I really had to work on making the spaces bigger to fill an actual book,” she says. “But it’s been very well received. I’ve continued to sell. I self-narrated it. How to Date Hot Older Women, very to the point.”
“It was fun. It was just, okay, here are my thoughts as a woman that some people think is hot. As an older woman, here’s what you should know as a younger guy about older women,” she says. “Here are your advantages, here’s what you have that’s not an advantage, and here’s how to play it. How to approach women and how to be in a relationship with an older woman, what they find valuable. It’s not the same as when they were 25. There are good things and bad things. It gets complicated with an older woman. There are usually a lot of different factors, versus a 25-year-old without any other obligations.”
“I self-narrated it and I’m really proud of that. It was a great process. It’s still available in paperback, on Audible and on Kindle on Amazon, and it continues to sell,” she says. “That one did really well.”
SOMETHING FOR THE SECOND ACT
Her second book is aimed at a different reader.
“The Second Act Success System is really about building an online business for women over 40 or 50: entrepreneurship, branding and publicity, media relations, content creation. I really go through what you’re going to learn, and you don’t need to be perfect, you don’t need to be 25,” she says. “I put a lot of love and a lot of work into this. I created it first as an online course through the Stan Store. It did very little. I worked so hard on it about a year ago and it just didn’t sell. So I worked really hard and made it into a book. That’s an evergreen thing.”
“The information isn’t just for people in the adult industry. It’s for anybody with a social media presence who wants to build a business,” she says. “When I was making this I was thinking about any woman in her second act, maybe she owns a plant store: how do they get out there and present themselves with consistency and a brand and an overall strategy?”
The industry, she says, supplies her with examples of what not to do.
“I see a lot of women in this industry who are hot and that’s all they know, so they throw spaghetti on the wall and see what sticks. They don’t have any strategy or consistency, or they don’t take advantage when somebody offers them an opportunity,” she says. “I give opportunities to people. I’ll say, ‘I know this person, you don’t live too far apart, that would be a good synergy for you to do content together.’ I can’t tell you how often nothing happens, and I’m just like, that is a wasted opportunity. I just basically handed you something I know could help you, and you didn’t seize it.”
Sales of the two books split along her audience.
“My bestseller is How to Date Hot Older Women, because that’s my fan base, guys,” she says. “That one was built for men. The other was made more for women.”
MAYBE I’LL JUST GO BLONDE AND MOVE TO GREECE
A literary agent approached her a couple of years ago, and St. James told her more of her story than the public has heard.
“She said, ‘From the little I knew about you, I thought it was a book. Now I not only think it’s a book, I think it’s a docu-series or a documentary,’” she says. “I would like to retire by the time I’m 65. I’d like to be out of this business. I don’t know what I’ll do. Maybe I’ll just go blonde and move to Greece. I’m not sure.”
“But I would love the opportunity to have a documentary or some sort of book, a memoir, that would showcase my life, because a lot happened before this and a lot has happened during this,” she says. “It’s a really interesting curve of a life that I’ve lived, filled with a lot of interesting twists and turns.”
IT’S A BUST
She still has a podcast, though not much is happening with it.
“I do still have a podcast. I haven’t been doing a lot with it, especially after YouTube made me take down so many of my try-on videos and age-gated them,” she says. “It was all about being a busty woman in life, and we called it, ‘It’s a Bust.’ YouTube really stopped liking me.”
“I’ll do more when it makes sense. What I found is that having other guests on didn’t really help me, and I’m not in this to be a podcaster. I’m in this to make money,” she says. “I’ve had some big names, Alexis Fox, Reagan Fox, Christie Canyon, big names as far as OnlyFans creators. But it’s just not where my focus is and where my time is best spent.”
A TREADMILL THAT NEVER ENDS
Pressed on the reality of the business, St. James doesn’t soften it.
“The reality is I’m constantly working. I’m constantly thinking about work. I’m constantly, constantly, constantly worried, and constantly trying to figure out what is going to bring me new fans and how I’m going to make my fans stay,” she says. “It’s constant. I feel like I’m on a treadmill and it never ends. There are a lot of things I love about it, and I’ve loved the experience, but I just didn’t realize the anxiety would still be here.”
“And I didn’t realize how many people would leave my life because I did this. That’s the reality. It’s honestly a lonely life, especially if you don’t have a partner, and I’ve heard this from other creators. It can be a very isolating, lonely life,” she says. “It’s a weird thing. You can have hundreds of thousands of followers, and then your daily life is small.”
JOKE’S ON THEM
The part of the journey that surprises her most is her own success.
“I think pushing my boundaries, and that I could still be successful at this age, that I could create this persona and this business and be successful, I’m delighted with that,” she says. “I’m delighted that I’ve been able to turn that into something, make the money and give my son a life I never could have imagined. I’m heavier and nearly 40 years older than when I wanted to be a model, and I’m more successful now than I could have ever imagined being a model when I was 20 years old or 18 years old, and I was told I was too fat, too old. I was too old at, like, 19.”
“It’s like, joke’s on them 40 years later,” she says. “Here I am, making six figures.”
Asked whether she appreciates the success more now than she would have earlier, she doesn’t hesitate.
“100%,” she says. “I went through such times of just being normal and working, the ups and downs of having a professional career, then becoming a mom and having to step back from that professional career and do what’s best to be a really good mom, which meant not making as much money. Then to get this later in life, of course I appreciate it.”
“It still brings me anxiety, because I want to make more and more and more. I just need a few more really good years,” she says. “When it fluctuates, that’s very tough on you. You’re like, is this over now? Am I never gonna be that successful again? Am I never gonna even get close to that again?”
HEART RICH
“I wake up and I go, wow, this is pretty cool,” she says, “because I was brought up in a generation where my mom said, ‘You disappear after the time you’re 40. You disappear as a woman after you’re 40. Guys just don’t notice you anymore.’ That’s what makes me heart rich, when I know that I can be this beacon.”
“I hear from fans and other creators, ‘You’re so positive, and I look up to you,’ or ‘We look up to you.’ It’s so inspiring to think that I could still be doing this, or I could step away and then come back in my fifties and do this,” she says. “I wasn’t anticipating being that beacon of light, but I love that. Even if it’s a guy that looks at me and goes, ‘Wow, you restarted your life after 50. It’s not all over.’ Maybe there’s still really good things to happen.”
“I want people to know that, because I’ve dealt with a lot of emotional struggles in my life,” she says. “To think that you might have hope of something great happening, it might not be that you’re an OnlyFans creator, but you might have some wonderful thing happen to you after you’re 50. If I can be an example of that, that makes me really happy.”
MAKE YOUR DAY A LITTLE BRIGHTER
St. James opened this conversation with Dolly Parton and the joke that was on everyone else. Her last words go to the people on the other side of the screen.
“Oh, well, they should be talking to me on my fan sites,” she says. “But if they’re not, you know, thank you. Thanks for giving validation to a woman who’s in her mid-fifties, just a regular Midwest mom who took an opportunity, took a risk, and it paid off. I hope that when you’re watching me, fans, followers, I just make your day a little brighter, even if it’s for half a second, even if it’s for a second. That’s my goal. Ultimately my goal is to bring smiles and make you feel something positive whenever you see my stuff.”
https://www.elainaverified.com/
https://www.instagram.com/elainastjames

Follow us on twitter: @emmreport, instagram @emmreport, tiktok@emmreport


+ There are no comments
Add yours